I like documentaries. I find them interesting, and often as informative as reading a book. I also appreciate them as a form of entertainment, and am always willing to view them as critically as any other thing I might read or listen to. That being said, two fascinating documentaries to watch back to back are "Super Size Me" and "Fat Head." One is a very well known documentary on the evils of fast food, and the other is an in-depth response to many of the claims of that documentary, as well as underlying superstitions that people hold in regards to nutrition.
I say "superstitions" because that's what they are--mass held beliefs unsupported (and, in fact, often disproved) by any scientific study. One of those is very well debunked in "Fat Head," where the documenter goes into great detail about cholesterol, as well as "good" and "bad" fat/cholesterol, as well as it's relationship with heart disease and health.
Most of what's in there is very well supported by true scientific fact, including the MOST IMPORTANT fact of all: high cholesterol in women is HEALTHY. In fact, low cholesterol in women leads to earlier deaths, and often very poor mental health. This is something my mom has known for years, particularly because she's had many different odd health problems that have caused her to do a lot of research into the commonly held beliefs about women's health.
My only true concern with the documentary's claims about fat and saturated fat, is that the way to get this fat is through the consumption of animal protein, which is "healthy" for us. This is where I unfortunately part ways with the documentary, as other in-depth studies that are notably unsupported by the government because they disprove nearly everything that the government supports (high grains, dairy products, and meat). Plant protein is much better for human kind, and that there are plenty of available fats in nuts that do a body very good.
One of the core arguments for "Fat Head" AND "Super Size Me" is the claim that we need to return to our "roots" as humans. That in our recent times, we've changed our diets radically from what we used to eat, and this is what is causing much of our problems. This is, at the basic level, extremely true.
We now eat a lot of chemicals, through pesticides, and even more importantly through genetically modified foods. We now eat mass produced food farmed using artificial fertilizers. We now have a diet that focuses on the regular consumption of easily accessible meat. We use dairy products of all sorts as a regular addition to nearly every single meal we eat. We now bake, cook, and fry a vast majority of our foods. We consume an incredible amount of artificially processed and created sugars in almost every type of food we consume.
What both of these documentaries ignore, however, is that animal proteins did not use to be a massively huge part of our diets as humans. In fact, when "Fat Head" claims that when we ate a high saturated fat diet of animal proteins that we were taller and more muscular, they're neglecting to mention that this was one of our early ancestors who were bred into EXTINCTION by the homo sapiens. Not a particularly compelling argument to be like them.
Human beings are omnivores only in the sense that we have developed an ability to consume animal proteins and meat out of a strong desire to survive. We are not developed in any way to eat meat daily, or even weekly. It was meant to be used as a last ditch effort to eat, and something that we could eat IF WE HAD NEED. We are not equipped with ANYTHING meant to take down another animal, and even the old argument of our teeth is bogus. We're meant to eat plants, fruits, nuts, roots, and other such things. We're not even meant to cook most of our food--other animals don't cook their food! This is something we learned to do that has, in fact, reduced the amount of nutrition we receive from our foods.
So, while most of the information present is good, and very helpful in debunking major lies that the TV and government tell us, it can be misleading. Drinking another animal's breast milk isn't a good source of anything meant for us. Eating another animal on a regular basis in not an appropriate diet. Eating food that we cook (or HAVE to cook in order to eat) are being consumed in a way that was not intended. Our bodies are not equipped with flame throwers--our stomachs were not created to only accept food that has been cooked.
Saying that we figured these things out with our brains, and that they are therefore "meant" to be is a faulty logic of epic proportions. In fact, even some of our biggest advancements of society through our brains (our "medicine" for example) are all things we developed to counter act the problems we created through our "development" of our diet and exercise beliefs. For example, rather than inventing an incredible system of dental care and oral hygiene...we could just stop eating an incredibly high diet of sugar, corn syrup, and carbohydrates from grains. But, unfortunately, we are too smart for that.
Recent Comments